Charlotte Corporate Counsel

For founders heading into a raise · Essay

Formation done right costs less than diligence cleanup

Published

You'll leave knowing which formation papers an investor's lawyer will re-open, and how to check yours before the list arrives.

Your term sheet is signed, and the investor's lawyer sends over the diligence list. Half of it asks for paperwork you meant to finish when you formed the company. Governance built correctly at formation costs a company far less than the cleanup that diligence forces later. Here's how to tell which shortcuts come back, and five checks to run on yours this week.

What an unfinished formation file costs you mid-raise

Cleanup hits you in three places at once. All three land while you're trying to close.

  • The clock

    Your closing date is already set. Every missing document is a finding to fix before the money moves.

  • The bill

    You pay for the repair, and you spend your own hours on it in the same weeks you're negotiating the round.

  • The signatures

    Some fixes need a signature from someone who left: the contractor who built your first release, or a co-founder who moved on.

None of that shows up on your cap table spreadsheet. It lives in the paper underneath.

Why the formation checklist didn't save you

You've heard the standard advice. Form a Delaware C corporation. Put founder vesting in place and file your 83(b) elections. Collect IP assignments, pick a cap table tool, and use standard financing documents.

That advice is sound, and following it puts you ahead. But a checklist tells you what to sign. It doesn't tell you which of those choices an investor's lawyer will actually re-open, what the fix costs in fees and weeks, or which items nobody asks about.

So when you decide whether to paper something now or later, you're guessing at the trade.

The better question: what will an investor's lawyer re-open?

Sort your formation paper by what diligence will re-read, and fix that first. It comes down to two questions: who owns your company, and what your company owns. Everything a raise re-opens answers one or the other.

“The structure underneath it all, built right at formation so it holds up at the next round.”

Corporate Governance, Charlotte Corporate Counsel

Who owns your company

At Charlotte Corporate Counsel, corporate governance is built around that question. It covers entity formation, operating agreements, founder agreements, ownership structuring, and equity purchase agreements. Each one answers a question your investor's lawyer will ask.

Take a cap table that shows two founders at an even split. If you can't produce a signed equity purchase agreement for each of them, the spreadsheet proves very little. If your operating agreement describes a different deal, you have a finding.

What your company owns

A technology company owns what it creates only if its contractor, collaboration and licensing paper says so, and shares it only on terms it set. So diligence follows your code, your brand, and your data back to the people who made them. Those signatures are easy while the people are still around and hard once they've moved on.

If you can't tell which side of that line your own file sits on, tell me about your deal.

If you have a co-founder, you also face the vesting call: paper it at formation, or wait for a priced round?

Charlotte Corporate Counsel to confirmShould two founders paper vesting at formation or wait for a priced round, and what is your reasoning when you advise them?

Won't fixing it now cost more than waiting?

It's a fair worry when cash is tight. The honest comparison is between a price you can see and one you can't.

Fix it now

Every engagement at Charlotte Corporate Counsel starts with a fixed-scope proposal. You know what you're getting and what it costs before any work begins. The intro call before that is free.

Fix it in diligence

Cleanup has no number until the list arrives. Its scope is whatever the list turns up, and its deadline is your closing. You're repairing documents while you negotiate the round.

That's the habit a finance-trained approach builds. I practiced at Baker Hostetler, Baker Donelson, and Kutak Rock before starting my own practice. I still read a formation decision like a funding plan: what does it cost now, and what does it cost at the next stage if it's wrong?

Charlotte Corporate Counsel to confirmWhen a client comes to you mid-raise with formation paper to fix, what has that cleanup cost in fees and delay compared with the fixed scope for doing it at formation?

Charlotte Corporate Counsel to confirmWhich formation items have you seen investors' counsel rarely or never ask about, so a founder can safely leave them for later?

Five checks to run before the diligence list arrives

Start with your own files. Each check matches something an investor's lawyer will ask to see.

  1. Match the cap table. Find a signed equity purchase agreement behind every founder's shares.
  2. Read your operating or founder agreement against how you actually run. Does it say who decides and who owns what, the way you work today?
  3. List everyone who built the product or the brand, founders and contractors included. Find each person's signed IP ownership agreement.
  4. List everyone with access to your code or customer data. Find their confidentiality and data access terms.
  5. Price the gaps now, as a fixed scope, before a term sheet sets the deadline for you.

Do that, and the next diligence list reads differently. It's a set of questions you've already answered.

Working on something like this? Tell Charlotte about your deal. A few lines is enough: what you're working on, and when you need it.

The short version

Which formation shortcuts get re-opened in a later raise?

The formation shortcuts a later raise re-opens are the ones that decide ownership. An investor's lawyer reads the paper under the cap table. Were founder shares issued under signed equity purchase agreements? Does the operating agreement match how the company runs? Did every founder and contractor who built the product sign an IP ownership agreement? Did everyone with access to code or customer data sign confidentiality terms? Each gap becomes a fix on the investor's deadline. I'm Charlotte Lynn Luu, and at Charlotte Corporate Counsel I build that paper at formation, with a fixed scope and cost set before work begins.

Questions founders ask about formation

Is structure built at formation cheaper than cleanup later?

Yes, in my view, because at formation you control the scope and the timing. In cleanup, the investor's list sets the scope and the closing sets the deadline.

What does working with Charlotte Corporate Counsel on formation look like?

It starts with a short intro call about your business and what's on the table. Then you get a fixed-scope proposal, and after the work is done, you have counsel you can call as the company grows.

What should a contractor sign before writing code for a startup?

An independent contractor agreement, an IP ownership agreement, and a confidentiality and data access agreement. Signed before the first commit, they settle who owns the code and what the contractor may do with your data.